Trump DOJ Folds, Agrees To Permanent Ban On Censoring ICE Tracking Group And App

Posted

Despite years of hype and nonsense about the Biden admin supposedly “censoring” people on social media, when that case finally went to court, it became clear that there was nothing behind it beyond a conspiracy theory. Yet when the Trump administration openly took credit for getting social media sites to suppress speech it didn’t like, it barely got any coverage at all. But, at least someone sued, and in a much lower profile case than the one during the Biden era, Trump’s Justice Department has now thrown in the towel and promised to stop censoring at least one ICE tracking group on social media.

You may recall that, back during the Biden admin, there was the huge Murthy case, involving two states (Missouri & Louisiana) and a crew of MAGA influencers insisting that the Biden admin had caused social media sites like Facebook and Twitter to “censor” their “conservative” views. While the case got some headline-grabbing rulings in the lower courts from famously Trump-supporting judges, by the time it reached the Supreme Court, most of the court (including Amy Coney Barrett, who wrote the opinion) realized that there was basically no actual evidence of Biden-admin coercion because it was almost entirely a MAGA-brained conspiracy theory.

The real issue in the case was understanding the difference between persuasion and coercion. The government is absolutely allowed to explain to platforms why it thinks that information should be removed, so long as there is no threat involved. Indeed, when the Murthy case was heard, two Justices from opposite ends of the Court’s ideological spectrum, both of whom had spent time as White House lawyers — Elena Kagan and Brett Kavanaugh — both mocked the lawyer representing the states for acting like it was a huge breach of decorum for the government to try to persuade private companies to do something.

JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: Do you think on the anger point, I guess I had assumed, thought, experienced government press people throughout the federal government who regularly call up the media and — and berate them. Is that — I mean, is that not —

MR. FLETCHER: I — I — I don’t want

JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: — your understanding? You said the anger here was unusual. I guess I wasn’t —

MR. FLETCHER: So that —

JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: — wasn’t entirely clear on that from my own experience.

And then Kagan:

JUSTICE KAGAN: I mean, can I just understand because it seems like an extremely expansive argument, I must say, encouraging people basically to suppress their own speech. So, like Justice Kavanaugh, I’ve had some experience encouraging press to suppress their own speech.

You just wrote about editorial. Here are the five reasons you shouldn’t write another one. You just wrote a story that’s filled with factual errors. Here are the 10 reasons why you shouldn’t do that again.

I mean, this happens literally thousands of times a day in the federal government.

When the eventual ruling came out, ACB pointed out five separate times the near total lack of evidence of coercion, and (in a footnote) pointed out that the lower court rulings arguing the opposite relied on “clearly erroneous” factual findings.

But, that didn’t mean the Supreme Court said it was fair game for government censorship, even if MAGA folks pretended that’s what the court said. Because the very same day that the Supreme Court heard the Murthy case, they also heard the Vullo case, which involved actual government coercion against intermediaries to suppress speech, in this case, targeting the NRA. The 9-0 ruling in that case (Vullo) made it quite clear that if there is actual government coercion against a third party to suppress speech, that violates the First Amendment.

Fast forward to the second Trump administration, which got into office partly based on the false claims that they supported free speech while the Democrats did not. They almost immediately set about creating a vast censorship machine (“we can do this the easy way or the hard way“) that they proudly bragged about.

One of those involved was then Attorney General Pam Bondi, calling up Apple and Facebook to get them to remove ICE tracking groups and apps. At the time, we wondered aloud why all the “free speech warriors” who spent years screaming about the “censorship industrial complex” under Biden suddenly went silent. Especially given that both Pam Bondi and then DHS Secretary Kristi Noem seemed gleeful about their abuse of power to censor people online:

In February of this year, Kassandra Rosado (who ran a Chicago-focused ICE tracking group on Facebook) and Mark Hodges (who created the Eyes Up app for archiving videos of ICE enforcement actions) sued the government, represented by FIRE. In April, the judge found that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in showing that Bondi violated the First Amendment in demanding such takedowns, and granted a preliminary injunction. In the ruling, Judge Jorge L. Alonso pointed out that, unlike in the Murthy case, here there was direct evidence that the companies only made their decisions because Pam Bondi threatened them:

First, Facebook had previously reviewed the Chicagoland group, and Apple had previously reviewed Eyes Up. In both cases, Facebook and Apple had determined that the content met their requirements. Second, Facebook and Apple changed their positions and removed the content immediately after Defendants contacted them about it. And third, Defendants made public statements taking credit for the fact that Facebook and Apple had removed the content.

[….]

Bondi and Noem also intimated that Facebook and Apple may be subject to prosecution for failing to comply with Bondi and Noem’s demands. For example, after stating that we “had Apple and Google take down the ICEBlock apps,” Bondi further stated: “We’re not going to stop at just arresting the violent criminals we can see in the streets.” … And in the same social media post where Noem wrote that “[p]latforms like Facebook must be PROACTIVE in stopping the doxxing of our [ICE] law enforcement,” she added: “We will prosecute those who dox our agents to the fullest extent of the law.” … Although these statements may not be direct threats to prosecute Facebook and Apple, they are intimations of a threat. And thinly veiled threats such as these constitute sufficient evidence on which Plaintiffs are likely to succeed on their claim.

On Thursday it became clear that the Trump DOJ was giving up. The two sides filed a joint motion to convert the preliminary injunction into a permanent injunction, which Judge Alonso quickly granted on Friday. In short, the government gave up even trying to justify its actions regarding the Eyes Up app and the Chicagoland ICE Sightings group. There’s no formal admission of wrongdoing here, but there doesn’t need to be. Rather than defend the very conduct Bondi and Noem had publicly bragged about, the DOJ agreed to be permanently barred from doing it again, and to send written notice of that to its own officials, Meta, and Apple within a week. Agencies that think they did nothing wrong don’t usually agree to letting an injunction stay in place, and to send a letter to companies notifying them of such a result.

The DOJ clearly knew it was going to lose badly, and agreed to the permanent injunction to get the case over with.

Of course, the injunction only applies to that one app and that one Facebook group, meaning that the DOJ could still try to suppress speech of other apps and other groups, but that would be just as unconstitutional, and Judge Alonso’s preliminary injunction ruling lays out exactly why. That said, there’s still a separate lawsuit, filed by EFF on behalf of the ICEBlock app under similar circumstances, where we’re still waiting for the judge to rule.

apple, facebook, 1st amendment, doj, donald trump, eyes up, free speech, ice, ice tracking, kassandra rosado, kristi noem, mark hodges, pam bondi